Michigan Courts Site Search 
 
  MICHIGAN COURTS  
  MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT


Nos. 123114 123115

David Sanchez,   Gary T. Neal (231) 726-4861

Plaintiff-Appellant, Cross-Appellee,

   
v    

Eagle Alloy, Inc., and

  Thomas H. Cypher (616) 774-2131
Second Injury Fund,   Victoria A. Keating (313) 456-0080

Defendants-Appellees, Cross-Appellants.

   
-------------------------------------------------------------    
Alejandro Vazquez,   John A. Braden (231) 830-9190

Plaintiff-Appellant, Cross-Appellee,

   
v.    

Eagle Alloy, Inc.,

   

Defendant-Appellee, Cross-Appellant.

   
_______________________________________    

Click to view briefs in Adobe format:

Plaintiffs-Appellants' Joint Brief on Appeal>>
Plaintiffs-Appellants, Cross-Appellees' Joint Brief on Appeal
Plaintiffs-Appellants' Brief in Reply to the Amicus Curiae Brief of  Michigan Self-Insurers' Assn>>

Defendant-Appellee Second Injury Fund's Brief on Appeal>>

Defendant-Appellee, Cross-Appellant Eagle Alloy, Inc.'s, Brief on Appeal

Michigan Migrant Legal Assistance Project, Inc., the National Employment
                   Law Project, West View Orchards & Cider Mill of Romeo, and
                   Zylstra Greenhouse's Amicus Curiae Brief>>

Michigan Self-Insurers' Association's Amicus Curiae Brief>>


Background
Daniel Sanchez and Alejandro Vazquez entered the country illegally and obtained work with the defendant-employer through the use of fake social security cards and other false identification. They also falsified answers about their legal status on their employment applications. Both men were injured at work. Sanchez's hand was crushed and burned in a press accident; Vazquez suffered a joint separation in his shoulder while lifting a heavy metal part. Sanchez and Vazquez were awarded various workers compensation benefits, and both parties appealed to the Court of Appeals. In a published opinion, the Court of Appeals held that benefits could be awarded, but that they must be suspended once the employer obtains confirmation of the plaintiffs legal status. The plaintiffs appeal.

Top of Page

Get the latest version of Internet Explorer. Some of the files on this site are PDF files. To view PDF files, you need Acrobat Reader. Download your free copy here.

Technical questions about this site should be sent to webinfo@courts.mi.gov.
Questions about the content on this site should be sent to msc-info@courts.mi.gov.