You may be trying to access this site from a secured browser on the server. Please enable scripts and reload this page.
This page location is:
Home
Case Search
pages
default
Sign In
Information for...
General Public
Media & News
Legal Community
Judges & Court Staff
Courts
One Court of Justice
Michigan Supreme Court
Michigan Court of Appeals
Michigan Trial Courts
Michigan Court of Claims
Native American Tribal Courts
Federal Courts
Cases, Opinions & Orders
Case Search
Opinion & Order Search
Opinion & Order Subscription
Business Courts Opinion Search
Administration
One Court of Justice
State Court Administrative Office
Judicial Information Services
Trial Court Administration
Employment Opportunities
Education & References
One Court of Justice
The Learning Center
Michigan Judicial Institute
Reports and Publications
Statistics
News & Events
One Court of Justice
Events Calendar
News Releases
Self Help
One Court of Justice
Self Help Center
Directories
Complaints
Administrative Hearing System
Request a Court Interpreter
Main Menu
Courts
Cases, Opinions & Orders
Administration
Education & References
News & Events
Self Help
Home
Cases, Opinions & Orders
Case Search
Print
By Docket Number
By Party Name
Case List By Attorney
Use the
By Docket Number
search to locate the Court docket sheet for a specific docket number. The docket number is also known as the case number.
Case Search Tips
Case Docket Number:
Select Court:
Supreme Court
Court of Appeals
Case Docket Number Search Results -
323425
Appellate Docket Sheet
COA Case Number:
323425
MSC Case Number:
154808
SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC V ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO
1
SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC
Oral Argument:
Timely: Y
PL-AE
RET
(23468)
SAPERSTEIN IRA B
CO
(31492)
GRANZOTTO MARK
2
SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL
DB
3
LETKEMANN JAMIE
Oral Argument:
Timely: Y
PL-AE
RET
(49463)
HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
4
ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY
Oral Argument: Y
Timely: Y
DF-AT
RET
(72000)
HANSEN NEIL
COA Status:
Case Concluded; File Archived
MSC Status:
Closed
09/02/2014
1
App For Leave to Appeal - Civil
Proof of Service Date
09/02/2014
Answer Due
09/23/2014
Fee Code
EPAY
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
Notice date modified bc reply defective-cure due 11/5
04/03/2014
2
Order Appealed From
From
WAYNE CIRCUIT COURT
Case Number
11-015300-NF
Trial Court Judge
26255 CURTIS DAPHNE MEANS
Nature of Case
Summary Disposition Denied
Comments
innocent third party
09/02/2014
3
Other
Date
09/02/2014
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
statement transcript of 3/14/14 hrg on mtn for SD ordered on 9/2/14
09/03/2014
4
Telephone Contact
For Party
1 SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC PL-AE
Attorney
23468 - SAPERSTEIN IRA B
Comments
vmail for AE's asst to confirm correct address & phone #
09/03/2014
5
Defective Holding File Letter
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
Letter sent to all parties.
09/09/2014
6
Telephone Contact
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
Rema called re curing defects
09/11/2014
7
Telephone Contact
For Party
1 SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC PL-AE
Attorney
23468 - SAPERSTEIN IRA B
Comments
Atty Gave Correct Address/Phone #; Also Stated Did NOT Rvc Cpy of App-Instructed to Contact AT
09/11/2014
9
Motion: Immediate Consideration
Proof of Service Date
09/11/2014
Filed By Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Answer Due
09/18/2014
09/11/2014
10
LCt Document
Date
09/11/2014
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
docket entries
09/15/2014
11
Correspondence Received
Date
09/12/2014
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
ltr from AT's office confirming parties involved in appeal, in response to defect ltr
09/17/2014
12
Transcript Requested By Atty Or Party
Date
09/17/2014
Reporter
6909 - JEFFERSON LAURIE A
Hearings
03/14/2014
09/19/2014
8
Telephone Contact
For Party
3 LETKEMANN JAMIE PL-AE
Attorney
49463 - HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
Comments
advised AE he has 21 days from date defects are cured to file answer
09/25/2014
13
Correspondence Received
Date
09/24/2014
For Party
1 SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC PL-AE
Attorney
23468 - SAPERSTEIN IRA B
Comments
change of address to 400 Galleria Officentre
09/30/2014
14
Steno Certificate - Tr Request Received
Date
09/17/2014
Reporter
6909 - JEFFERSON LAURIE A
Hearings
03/14/2014
10/02/2014
16
Telephone Contact
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
called AT;spoke w/asst;she advised 10/27 trial adjourned;no new date;told me to ask for Rima re tran
10/02/2014
17
Telephone Contact
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
vmail for Rima;need TR & pos on parties ASAP;need call once new trial date set
10/02/2014
18
Answer - Application
Proof of Service Date
10/02/2014
Event No
1 App For Leave to Appeal - Civil
For Party
1 SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC PL-AE
Filed By Attorney
23468 - SAPERSTEIN IRA B
Comments
joint answer for parties 1-3 signed by aty Christopher Hastings and atty Ira Sapterstein
10/21/2014
19
Reply to Answer - Application
Proof of Service Date
10/21/2014
Event No
18 Answer - Application
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Filed By Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
10/22/2014
20
Defective Filing Letter
Event
19
Defect
EXCEEDED PAGE LIMIT - Cured
11/03/2014
23
Defect Cured
Event
19
P/S Date
11/03/2014
Defect
EXCEEDED PAGE LIMIT - Cured
11/10/2014
22
Telephone Contact
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
called AT for status on TR; he will call ct rep and call back
11/18/2014
25
Submitted on Motion Docket
Event
1 App For Leave to Appeal - Civil
Event
9 Immediate Consideration
District
D
Item #
4
11/25/2014
26
Order: Application - Grant
View document in PDF format
Event
1 App For Leave to Appeal - Civil
Event
9 Immediate Consideration
Panel
MJR,CMM,KFH
Immediate Consideration Granted
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
Judge Hood would DENY application
12/11/2014
27
Brief: Appellant
Proof of Service Date
12/11/2014
Oral Argument Requested
Y
Timely Filed
Y
Filed By Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
01/06/2015
28
Invol Dismissal Warning - No Dkt Stmt
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Due Date
01/27/2015
01/06/2015
29
Stips: Extend Time - AE Brief
Extend Until
02/12/2015
Filed By Attorney
49463 - HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
For Party
3 LETKEMANN JAMIE PL-AE
P/S Date
01/06/2015
01/13/2015
32
Docketing Statement MCR 7.204H
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Proof of Service Date
01/13/2015
Filed By Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
01/15/2015
33
Telephone Contact
Date
01/15/2015
For Party
1 SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC PL-AE
Attorney
23468 - SAPERSTEIN IRA B
Comments
W/ Atty Saperstein Assistant, Atty Will not be Appearing on Behalf of SE MI, Pty 1
02/12/2015
34
Brief: Appellee
Proof of Service Date
02/12/2015
Timely Filed
Y
Filed By Attorney
49463 - HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
For Party
3 LETKEMANN JAMIE PL-AE
Joint Parties
1
02/13/2015
35
Defective Filing Letter
Event
34
Defect
Proof of Service - Cured
02/13/2015
36
Noticed
Record
REQST
Mail Date
02/17/2015
02/13/2015
37
Proof of Service - Generic
Date
02/13/2015
For Party
3 LETKEMANN JAMIE PL-AE
Attorney
49463 - HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
Comments
P/S on Atty Hansen to Cure Defect in Evt#34
02/19/2015
38
Defect Cured
Event
34
P/S Date
02/13/2015
Defect
Proof of Service - Cured
02/24/2015
39
Record Filed
Comments
files(2)
03/04/2015
41
Brief: Reply
Proof of Service Date
03/04/2015
Filed By Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Comments
Please see amended reply brf - evt 43
03/05/2015
42
Defective Filing Letter
Event
41
Defect
Other - Cured
03/16/2015
43
Brief: Amended - Reply
Proof of Service Date
03/16/2015
Filed By Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Comments
Amended as to correct number of pages - 10
03/16/2015
44
Defect Cured
Event
41
P/S Date
03/16/2015
Defect
Other - Cured
11/16/2015
48
Record Request Letter - Level 1
Attorney
42783 - FARRAR CHARLES P
Comments
Req tr 3/14/14 on or about;all mot cross mot for summ disp
12/01/2015
49
Material Received by Record Room
Comments
Motions for summ disp
12/01/2015
51
Telephone Contact
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
Per atty still trying to obtain tr of 3/14/14
12/03/2015
52
Telephone Contact
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
Comments
Per Rima;w/bring tr of 3/14/14 to coa tomorrow
12/04/2015
53
Level 1 Record Request Satisfied
Comments
tr 3/14/14
12/04/2015
55
Notice Of Filing Transcript
Date
12/03/2015
Reporter
6909 - JEFFERSON LAURIE A
Hearings
03/14/2014
Comments
Refile
12/17/2015
56
Transcript Filed
Comments
tr copy 3/14/14
01/21/2016
66
Motion: Oral Argument on Case Call
Proof of Service Date
01/21/2016
Filed By Attorney
49463 - HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
For Party
3 LETKEMANN JAMIE PL-AE
Fee Code
EPAY
Answer Due
01/28/2016
01/22/2016
67
Submitted on Motion Docket Affecting Call
Event
66 Oral Argument on Case Call
District
D
Item #
1
01/27/2016
68
Order: Oral Argument - Grant
View document in PDF format
Event
66 Oral Argument on Case Call
Panel
AK,DHS,CDS
Attorney
49463 - HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
01/27/2016
69
Verbal Order to Parties-Phone
Comments
Read content of ord to secretary for aty Hastings;LEFT v/m mes for secretary to aty Hasen
01/27/2016
70
Case Call Update For Panel
Comments
Aty Hastings on behalf of the appellee has been granted oral argument
02/09/2016
60
Submitted on Case Call
District
D
Item #
11
Panel
AK,DHS,CDS
02/09/2016
72
Oral Argument Audio
08/09/2016
78
Opinion - Authored - Published
View document in PDF format
Pages
6
Panel
AK,DHS,CDS
Author
AK
Result
Reversed and Remanded
Comments
Remanded for further proceedings consistent with Opinion.
08/09/2016
79
Opinion - Partial Concurrence/Dissent
View document in PDF format
Pages
2
Author
DHS
08/30/2016
81
Motion: Reconsideration of Opinion
Proof of Service Date
09/08/2016
Filed By Attorney
49463 - HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
For Party
3 LETKEMANN JAMIE PL-AE
Fee Code
EPAY
Answer Due
09/22/2016
08/31/2016
82
Defective Filing Letter
Event
81
Defect
Other - Cured
08/31/2016
83
Order: Conflict Panel - Declined on Judges' Poll
View document in PDF format
Panel
MJT
Comments
All COA Judges - Special Panel Shall Not Convene
09/08/2016
84
Telephone Contact
For Party
3 LETKEMANN JAMIE PL-AE
Attorney
49463 - HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
Comments
Notified atty that defect cure was missing POS showing party 1.
09/08/2016
85
Defect Cured
Event
81
P/S Date
09/08/2016
Defect
Other - Cured
Comments
Opinion and POS curing defect uploaded to motion at event 81.
09/12/2016
87
Defective Filing Letter
Event
86
Defect
PROOF OF SERVICE - Cured
09/19/2016
86
Answer - Reconsideration
Proof of Service Date
09/19/2016
Event No
81 Reconsideration of Opinion
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Filed By Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
09/19/2016
88
Defect Cured
Event
86
P/S Date
09/19/2016
Defect
PROOF OF SERVICE - Cured
Comments
Answer with POS uploaded to event no. 86.
09/27/2016
89
Submitted on Reconsideration Docket
Event
81 Reconsideration of Opinion
District
C
Item #
1
10/12/2016
90
Order: Reconsideration - Deny - Appeal Remains Closed
View document in PDF format
Event
81 Reconsideration of Opinion
Panel
AK,DHS,CDS
Attorney
49463 - HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER J
11/22/2016
91
SCt: Application for Leave to SCt
Supreme Court No
154808
Answer Due
12/20/2016
Fee
E-Pay
For Party
1
Attorney
31492 - GRANZOTTO MARK
11/22/2016
92
SCt Case Caption
Proof Of Service Date
11/22/2016
12/07/2016
93
SCt Motion: Amicus - Leave Application
Party
5
Filed by Attorney
51149 - JUNE ROBERT B
Comments
MI Assn for Justice; brief attached
12/14/2016
94
SCt Order: Chief Justice - Grant
View document in PDF format
Comments
Grant MAJ motion to participate as AC and to file AC brf.
12/16/2016
95
Supreme Court - File & Record Sent To
File Location
Z
Comments
sc#154808 2 lcf;2 tr;lc plds
12/16/2016
96
SCt: COA and TCt Received
2 tr; 2 files
12/20/2016
97
SCt: Answer - SCt Application/Complaint
Filing Date
12/20/2016
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Filed By Attorney
72000 - HANSEN NEIL
04/03/2017
100
Michigan Appeals Reports Publication
316 Mich App 657
05/17/2017
101
SCt Order: Abeyance - Grant
View document in PDF format
Comments
Hold in abeyance pending decision in MSC No. 154442, Bazzi v Sentinel Ins Co.
04/05/2019
104
SCt Order: Remand to COA
View document in PDF format
04/05/2019
105
Record Filed
File Location
Comments
2 lcf;2 tr;misc plds--SC Remand
04/05/2019
106
Supreme Court - File Ret`d by - Re-Open for Reconsideration
File Location
L
04/08/2019
107
Appearance - Appellee
Date
04/08/2019
For Party
1 SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC PL-AE
Attorney
31492 - GRANZOTTO MARK
Comments
Granzotto Appear As Co-Counsel For Parties 1 and 3
04/11/2019
108
Motion: Supplemental Brief
Proof of Service Date
04/11/2019
Filed By Attorney
31492 - GRANZOTTO MARK
For Party
1 SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC PL-AE
Fee Code
EPAY
Answer Due
04/18/2019
04/24/2019
109
Re-Submitted Per Supreme Court Remand
District
L
Item #
0
04/24/2019
110
Submitted on Motion Docket Affecting Call
Event
108 Supplemental Brief
District
C
04/25/2019
111
Order: Supplemental Brief - Grant
View document in PDF format
Event
108 Supplemental Brief
Panel
AK,DHS,CDS
Attorney
31492 - GRANZOTTO MARK
Extension Date
05/16/2019
Comments
DF Response Brief Due w/in 21 Days of Proof/Service Date of PL's Supplemental Brief
05/06/2019
112
Telephone Contact
Comments
Left Msg For Saperstein; Need Current Mailing Address; 4/25/2019 Order Ret'd As Undeliverable
05/16/2019
113
Brief: Supplemental Brief - AE
Proof of Service Date
05/16/2019
Timely Filed
Y
Filed By Attorney
31492 - GRANZOTTO MARK
For Party
1 SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL LLC PL-AE
Joint Parties
3
Comments
Exhibits are attached to event but not printed for the file because of the volume.
06/06/2019
115
Brief: Supplemental Brief - AT
Proof of Service Date
06/06/2019
Oral Argument Requested
Timely Filed
Filed By Attorney
72315 - ANSTETT JENNIFER R
For Party
4 ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY DF-AT
Comments
On Remand; Accepted Per COA Order Issued 4/25/2019
06/19/2019
118
Order: Remand
View document in PDF format
Panel
AK,DHS,CDS
08/19/2019
119
File Closed-Out
File Location
F
Comments
record returned** 2 lcf;2 tr;misc plds--wayne circ
Case Listing Complete
Use the
By Party Name
search to locate the Court docket sheet for a specific party name. The party name can be the name of an individual or organization.
Case Search Tips
Party Name:
(Lastname Firstname Middle Initial OR Company Name)
Show Open Cases Only
Use the
Case List by Attorney
search to locate all Court docket sheets for a specific attorney. You can search by either attorney bar number or attorney name.
Case Search Tips
Bar Number:
P
Attorney Name:
Show Open Cases Only